When is comes to upgrading your bathroom, one of the biggest decisions you’ll make is choosing what your shower or bath will consist of. Two popular choices are Tile and Onyx. Both offer unique benefits, but depending on your lifestyle, timeline, and long-term goals, one may stand out as a better fit.
Design & Customization
Tile Showers:
Tile offers almost unlimited design possibilities. You can mix and match patterns, colors, finishes, and layouts to reflect your exact vision. Want a mosaic niche or a herringbone accent wall? Tile makes it possible. This is where tile really shines – it’s all about personal expression and craftsmanship.
Onyx Showers:
Onyx might seem more “standard” at first glance, but it’s surprisingly versatile. You can still choose from a wide selection of colors, edge profiles, base shapes, and even wall panel textures. While you won’t get the intricate patterns like tile, but Onyx gives you a clean, modern look with plenty of room for customization – just in a sleeker, more unified way.
Installation Time
Tile Showers:
Installing tile is a multi-step process that takes time and skill. From prepping the surface to laying each tile, grouting, sealing, and drying – it can stretch out over several days, sometimes longer depending on complexity. It’s worth it for a custom look, but it can mean more time without a functioning shower.
Onyx Showers:
One of Onyx’s biggest perks is how quickly it installs. Since it’s a pre-fabricated, made-to-order system, installation is faster and cleaner. In many cases, you can have your new shower fully installed in just a day or two – with far less dust, noise, and disruption to your home.
Maintenance & Durability
Tile Showers:
Grout can be the Achille’s heal of a tile shower. It requires sealing and regular maintenance to avoid staining, mildew, or cracking over time. Tile itself is very durable, but poorly installed or maintained grout can lead to water damage behind the scenes – something no homeowner wants to deal with.
Onyx Showers:
Onyx panels are non porous and grout-free, which means cleaning is a breeze. Just a soft cloth and a gentle cleaner will keep it looking brand new. There’s no grout to scrub, reseal, or worry about. It’s incredibly durable and resistant to mold, mildew, and everyday wear, making it a practical choice for a busy households, landlords and anyone who wants less upkeep.
Cost Considerations
Tile Showers:
Tile can range in price significantly based on the materials you choose – ceramic, porcelain, marble, etc. Labor is also a major factor. Because of the skill involved, installation costs can add up quickly, especially for intricate layouts or larger spaces. You’re paying for artistry, time and quality.
Onyx Showers:
Onyx is more cost-effective overall. While the material itself is not the cheapest you are getting quality for less, plus the reduced labor over time and lower maintenance costs long-term can save you money. Plus, you’re getting a product backed by a warranty and manufactured to fit your space – no surprises, no hidden to find later.
Long-Term Value & Lifestyle Fit
Tile Showers:
If you’re building your forever home or want that luxurious, spa-like aesthetic, tile can absolutely deliver. It adds a high-end, classic appeal – but it’s not always ideal for those who want a low maintenance lifestyle. Tile is perfect for people who value artistry and are okay with the up keep.
Onyx Showers:
Onyx is built for real life. It’s a smart investment for any homeowner, you get the simplicity and durability with a peace of mind. Whether you’re aging in place, remodeling a master or guest bath, or just want something beautiful that wont break your back to maintain, Onyx is designed to make your bathroom beautiful and your life easier.
Our Recommendation
While tile offers an unmatched beauty and customization, Onyx wins for homeowners who want something timeless, functional, and low-maintenance. It’s a no-fuss solution that still feels high-end. If you want to remodel your shower and get back to enjoying your bathroom – not scrubbing grout lines (Or heavy chemical sprays) then Onyx Shower Systems is an excellent choice.
Ready to upgrade your bathroom?
Let Integrity Construction and Restoration help you choose the perfect system for your home and lifestyle. Whether you’re leaning toward a custom tile design or the simplicity of Onyx, we’ll make sure it’s done right – with the care, precision, and integrity we’re known for.
Take a look at some of our bathroom remodels here
Have a look at what Onyx has to offer you
